That is exactly what occurred on the first day of trading in 2025. The Dow was up nearly 350 points in early trading Thursday, but closed down 151 points. The NASDAQ was up more than 200 points early on, but lost ground throughout the session, closing with a small (-30 points) loss.
The same was true for the S&P, which was up more than 50 points around 10:00 am ET, then fell 50 points into the red, finally rallying late in the day to register a smallish, 13-point loss.
After sprouting solid gains for the first 11 months of 2024, December was a decided departure from the norm, as the major indices were all down for the month, though the high-flying NASDAQ, dominated by the Magnificent 7, was down only marginally.
These patterns have been re-appearing on a regular basis and do not bode well for the "January Effect" which posits that "as goes January, so goes the rest of the year.
Analysts can pound the table as much as thye like about their year-end projections of stock gains, but the evidence thus far is lacking. Stocks remain wildly overvalued and incoming Trump policies and actions by his chief leiutenants will have profound effects on trading once implemented after January 20.
Expect similar results on a regular basis up until the inauguration. After that, stocks could spiral down without much support.
Gold, silver, and oil posted gains on January 2, but precious metals are under pressure leading to the opening bell. As usual, stocks are poised for a higher open by equity futures. Oil continues to push forward for no good reason, topping $73.50 in early trading, the highest since mid-October.
This being the first Friday of the month, normally non-farm payroll results (December) would be posted. Since the date is so close to the beginning of the month and the past two weeks were interrupted by holidays, the slavish BLS obviously needs more time to fudge the numbers.
Tread lightly, and carry a big stick, preferably made of gold or silver (quite heavy).
At the Close, Thursday, January 2, 2025:
Dow: 42,392.27, -151.95 (-0.36%)
NASDAQ: 19,280.79, -30.00 (-0.16%)
S&P 500: 5,868.55, -13.08 (-0.22%)
NYSE Composite: 19,095.42, -1.69 (-0.01%)