Trends Take Time; Why Tuesday's Sharp Gains Should Be Discounted

Less than 24 hours after making the bold proclamation that the bull market was over, Wall Street traders seem to disagree, sending the Dow Industrials up nearly 400 points at the open, with the Transportation Index cruising 130 points to the upside when the bell rang to start trading.

Days like this are precisely why investing is a longer-term proposition. Markets can turn on a dime, on a word from some prominent investor (see: Warren Buffett), a Fed President, a presidential tweet or even something more innocuous, like the trade balance (a new record, ignored), or jobs data (a bad miss on Friday, not ignored).

It's imperative to maintain perspective and not question what your own eyes told you a day ago, a week ago a month ago. In fact, for the Dow Theory components to finally trigger a sell signal took nearly three months from start to finish, all that time merely suggesting something ominous, before finally saying, "yes, here it is."

Tuesday's massive bounce contained no earth-shattering qualities in and of itself. The way the markets have been performing of late, one could hypothesize an equally violent downturn on Wednesday, Thursday, or Friday, though it appears the bulls are discounting the Dow Theory as a false flag for now. One wonders what the perma-bulls will be eating come June - steak tartar or boiled crow?

Instead of taking a short-term approach and admitting one was/is wrong, it's likely a better plan to look back at the charts and see exactly where the Dow Jones Industrial Average has to go before making a judgement on the efficaciousness of Dow Theory. I's a simple number: 26,616.71, the high from January 26, and the Transportation Index would have to close above 11,373.38, the all-time high from January 12.

Those numbers are far away, so the test will come over the coming weeks of earnings releases, when Wall Street and the financial news-speakers on CNBC, Bloomberg, and Fox Financial Network will be falling over each other to proclaim the greatness of the latest "beat." Bear in mind that all of these funny numbers coming out over the next three weeks, especially the EPS (earnings per share) figures, have all been manipulated by stock buybacks, diluting the number of shares outstanding, and in many cases, by lowered expectations by analysts. The true comparisons can be found from year-ago EPS (i.e., growth) and gross revenue numbers.

So, despite the snorting of the bull for a day, reserving judgement on a dead-cat, one-day wonder of a rally may be not only prudent, but prescient.

Dow Jones Industrial Average April Scorecard:

Date	Close	Gain/Loss	Cum. G/L
4/2/18	23,644.19	-458.92	-458.92
4/3/18	24,033.36	+389.17	-69.75
4/4/18	24,264.30	+230.94	+161.19
4/5/18	24,505.22	+240.92	+402.11
4/6/18	23,932.76	-572.46	-170.35
4/9/18	23,979.10	+46.34	-134.01
4/10/18	24,407.86	+428.76	+294.66

At the Close, Tuesday, April 10, 2018:
Dow Jones Industrial Average: 24,407.86, +428.76 (+1.79%)
NASDAQ: 7,094.30, +143.96 (+2.07%)
S&P 500: 2,656.85, +43.69 (+1.67%)
NYSE Composite: 12,575.63, +195.08 (+1.58%)