Stocks Creamed At Opening, Rally For Minor Losses

As mentioned in the most recent post, stocks tested a variety of support levels on Tuesday and actually crashed right through them early in the session.

But, about 10:30 am ET, a rally began, first in fits and starts, but by noon, it was well underway, lifting stocks well off their lows and continuing until... until... well, no, the major indices didn't turn positive, not even for a fleeting instant. By 3:00 pm all of the "greater fools" had been had, the dip buyers had bought all the dips they could and stocks drifted slightly lower into the close.

What started with the Dow down nearly 550 points, the NASDAQ off by more than 200, the S&P losing more than 60 points and the NYSE Composite down 264, ended with merely pedestrian losses and investors wiping the sweat from their furrowed brows. Once again, as has happened so many times during the Fed-led bull market of the 2010s, stocks averted catastrophe and sailed through the day thanks to so-called bargain hunters, that rare breed of speculators who believe buying a stock that's three to five percent off its highs is some kind of grand deal.

This is more than likely the coordinated work of central banks, who are not ever audited, who can created limitless amounts of funny money with the push of a button, and who have done so regularly in order to keep alive the dreams of prosperity and financial security for millions, by inventing - and then investing - trillions.

Behind the scene presented to the unsuspecting, unprofessional investing class - those people with retirements and life savings locked into 401k and other accounts - there was real damage. One index that did not recover very well at all was the Dow Jones Transportation Index, which slipped 199 points, to 10,237.02, a loss of 1.90%, sending it well below the key level of 10,397.23, its most recent low, from October 11, while also descending into correction territory for a second time this month, below 10,413.

With the transports falling like a bowling ball off a cliff, the importance of transportation to the rest of the economy has to be put into question. If nothing's moving, or, at least moving with less alacrity and determination, how strong is the whole economy? With their relevance to the Industrials via Dow Theory and in real life practice, the transports are the answer in search of a question, the question being how long can the slip-slide-recover charade continue before the bottom falls completely out?

The other fly in the financial ointment is, and has been, oil. WTI crude lost ground again today, sliding more than four percent into the low-$66 range, well off the $76/barrel high recently achieved. Not to offer a punnish perception, but oil greases the skids of industry and transportation. Lower pricing for the world's most vital commodity can mean one of three things: 1) lack of demand, 2) oversupply, 3) global recession. Of course, a combination of all three might be the correct analysis, though the implications of such a paroxysm might trigger a more virile reaction amongst the monied class.

Considering the ramifications of the major indices falling straight through support levels and then rebounding to more respectable levels, plus the demise of oil and the transports, one can easily conclude that the October volatility that has been apparent since the start of the month is nowhere near abatement. Even the mediocre losses today add to somebody's misery, though the pain felt is being doled out in small units, much like Chinese water torture, rather than having investors suffer the quick blade of the guillotine in a sudden crash (that may be saved for closer to the mid-term elections).

Stating the very, very obvious, this is far from over.

Dow Jones Industrial Average October Scorecard:

Date	Close	Gain/Loss	Cum. G/L
10/1/18	26,651.21	+192.90	+192.90
10/2/18	26,773.94	+122.73	+315.63
10/3/18	26,828.39	+54.45	+370.08
10/4/18	26,627.48	-200.91	+169.17
10/5/18	26,447.05	-180.43	-11.26
10/8/18	26,486.78	+39.73	+28.47
10/9/18	26,430.57	-56.21	-27.74
10/10/18	25,598.74	-831.83	-859.57
10/11/18	25,052.83	-545.91	-1,405.48
10/12/18	25,339.99	+287.16	-1,118.32
10/15/18	25,250.55	-89.44	-1,207.76
10/16/18	25,798.42	+547.87	-659.89
10/17/18	25,706.68	-91.74	-751.63
10/18/18	25,379.45	-327.23	-1,078.86
10/19/18	25,444.34	+64.89	-1,013.97
10/22/18	25,317.41	-126.93	-1,140.90
10/23/18	25,191.43	-125.98	-1,265.88

At the Close, Tuesday, October 23, 2018:
Dow Jones Industrial Average: 25,191.43, -125.98 (-0.50%)
NASDAQ: 7,437.54, -31.09 (-0.42%)
S&P 500: 2,740.69, -15.19 (-0.55%)
NYSE Composite: 12,287.44, -87.33 (-0.71%)

WARNING: Stocks Tumble Again, Key Levels About To Be Tested; Corporate Bag-Holders

As noted in the most recent WEEKEND WRAP, major US indices have been stretched lower to plumb their 200-day moving averages, with the NYSE Composite already having broken well below its 200-day.

While Monday's declines were not extraordinary, they were - with the obvious defection of the NASDAQ - uniform. Lock-step movement of the majors is usually cause for alarm, either to the upside or down, and, in this case, the S&P, Dow and Composite have been displaying the kind of cascading losses indicative that the move is not contained within a few select sectors, but rather, is broadly-based.

US stocks are not the only issues facing lower pricing. Stock indices around the world have been under severe pressure for most of October, extending back into August and September for most of Europe. Emerging markets, suffering losses most of the year - in the case of China, the decline began in 2015 - show no signs of recovering, their slide relentless and often violent.

Overnight, Hong Kong's Hang Send and Japan's NIKKEI indices were battered, the Hang Sent down, 3.06%, the NIKKEI off 2.67%. China's SSE Composite, already a basket case down more than 50% since 2015, fell another 2.26%.

Early on Tuesday, all European stock markets were lower. As has been the case for the past eight weeks, Germany's DAX was leading the way down.

When markets open in the US on Tuesday, the expectation if for further declines, as futures predict a very rough opening. S&P futures were off by as much as 37 points, NASDAQ futures were down more than 125 points, and Dow futures had fallen by more than 400 points by 8:00 am ET.

The immediate key levels for the major indices are obvious ones, as markets close in on the October 11 interim bottoms. The Dow is looking at its close of 25,051.55 on that date. Any intra-day move below that level would likely trigger even more selling pressure, as once again, Dow Theory rears its head, predicating a primary trend change from bullish to bearish.

Confirmation would come from the Transportation Index, which closed on October 11 at 10,397.23 and Monday at 10,435.76. Monday's loss of just three points on the transports was a shallow shadow of what's been an ugly performance since mid-September. Any close below 10,413 would put the index in correction territory, which was not reported on the October 11 flush.

As the S&P approaches its October 11 low of 2728.37, it is still three to four percentage points above correction (-10%), but the index has been hammered down of late with lower closing prices in 11 of the last 13 trading sessions.

The aforementioned NYSE Composite needs a close of 12,273 to qualify for correction mode. Its high dates all the way back to January 26, when it closed at an all-time high of 13,637.02. The composite is down more than nine percent from the highs and is down 3.6% year-to-date.

NASDAQ watchers will be eyeing the level of 7329.06, the October 11 closing low, after the index reached an all-time high of 8109.54 on August 31. A close of 7298 would be a 10% decline from that level.

Since October is traditionally the most volatile month, companies and investors will be seeking scapegoats and already some corporate types have singled out the threat or imposition of tariffs by President Trump as the primary cause for poor third quarter results.

Some analysts have touted the recent selloff as technical in nature, without important underlying rationale. Taking the case further afield, a recent note by JP Morgan analysts infers that the selling is not only technical in nature, but driven by the lack of corporate stock buybacks, typically halted or blacked out during earnings seasons.

The MarketWatch article which references the analysis is fascinating and full of charts and figures comparing the October breakdown to February's quickly-accelerating descent.

What the analysts fail to point out in their notes is that stocks rose dramatically during second quarter earnings season, from the end of June to near the end of July, putting the lie to their thesis. Stock buybacks have been the main driver of stocks since the aftermath of the 2008-09 crash, and are poised this year to reach a record above $900 billion.

At least, when stocks rebound near the end of the month (as the analysis suggests), we can finally proclaim to know just who those infamous buy the dip punters have been. If indications of a bear market continue to emerge, America's finest corporations, led by the best and brightest managers, will be the ultimate bag-holders, repurchasing their own stock at grossly elevated prices.

Only in America...

Dow Jones Industrial Average October Scorecard:

Date	Close	Gain/Loss	Cum. G/L
10/1/18	26,651.21	+192.90	+192.90
10/2/18	26,773.94	+122.73	+315.63
10/3/18	26,828.39	+54.45	+370.08
10/4/18	26,627.48	-200.91	+169.17
10/5/18	26,447.05	-180.43	-11.26
10/8/18	26,486.78	+39.73	+28.47
10/9/18	26,430.57	-56.21	-27.74
10/10/18	25,598.74	-831.83	-859.57
10/11/18	25,052.83	-545.91	-1,405.48
10/12/18	25,339.99	+287.16	-1,118.32
10/15/18	25,250.55	-89.44	-1,207.76
10/16/18	25,798.42	+547.87	-659.89
10/17/18	25,706.68	-91.74	-751.63
10/18/18	25,379.45	-327.23	-1,078.86
10/19/18	25,444.34	+64.89	-1,013.97
10/22/18	25,317.41	-126.93	-1,140.90

At the Close, Monday, October 22, 2018:
Dow Jones Industrial Average: 25,317.41, -126.93 (-0.50%)
NASDAQ: 7,468.63, +19.60 (+0.26%)
S&P 500: 2,755.88: -11.90 (-0.43%)
NYSE Composite: 12,374.76, -82.51 (-0.66%)

Weekend Wrap: Stocks Still Shaky; NYSE Composite Collapsed

Friday's split markets didn't offer much in the way of either relief or direction as stocks spent the majority of the week languishing around recent lows. Other than Tuesday's spectacular "all clear" melt-up, the week as a whole offered another indication that either a correction or the beginning of a bear market is already underway.

Without the huge upside surprise of Tuesday - a very suspicious event that occurred out of the blue without any obvious motivating factor - the major indices would have broken down through key supports. As it is, the S&P and NASDAQ are resting right on their 200-day moving averages, while the Dow is somewhere in between its 200 and 50-day MA.

The NASDAQ fell for the ninth time in 12 sessions, the S&P, dropped 10 of the last 12, but the clearest message is being delivered by the most overlooked and broadest index, the NYSE Composite, which has clearly crossed the Rubicon into a dark area of investor despair, already having crashed through its 200-day moving average a week ago and trading well below it since.

Professionals notice these kinds of things, while the general public is usually informed of cataclysmic events after the fact. Closer inspection of the Composite reveals that not only is it down about three percent for the year, but it has spent the majority of 2018 in the red, having never fully recovered from February's free-fall like the other, more-favored indices.

Should anyone be worried? Of course. Worry is one of the great equalizing factors in markets. Anybody who fantasizes that stocks will go up without correction is fuzzy-headed. There is (or should be) a constant tiny voice in the back of one's head urging caution, conservation, and preservation. It's a natural instinct, as much a part of human nature as having two eyes. In some, the trait is over-developed, but for most, it's well-hidden, back behind the modern day facade of bliss and happiness.

This kind of media conditioning is nothing new, but it can be particularly dangerous to avoid asking hard questions when it comes to capital and investments. Thinking that "everything will be fine," or "the government will take care of it," only reinforces attitude hat somebody else has one's best interests in mind when the reality is more likely the complete opposite. In centuries past, financial welfare was more akin to warfare. People had to fight for everything in their lives. It is only in the past 100 years that "civilized" society has allowed the common man and woman to delegate factors of economic survival and prosperity to outsiders. The result has been positive for many, but it has also produced a sizable divergence: creating a small super-wealthy class that controls more financial assets than 90% of the population combined.

Thus, it the 10% or one-percenters who are currently moving the markets, as is normally the case. Ceding control over one's finances is a modern-day contrivance that has benefitted the rich more than the middle and lower classes, and they're going to move the markets in the ways that benefit themselves most. Whether or not that is beneficial to the general population is another question altogether.

Dow Jones Industrial Average October Scorecard:

Date	Close	Gain/Loss	Cum. G/L
10/1/18	26,651.21	+192.90	+192.90
10/2/18	26,773.94	+122.73	+315.63
10/3/18	26,828.39	+54.45	+370.08
10/4/18	26,627.48	-200.91	+169.17
10/5/18	26,447.05	-180.43	-11.26
10/8/18	26,486.78	+39.73	+28.47
10/9/18	26,430.57	-56.21	-27.74
10/10/18	25,598.74	-831.83	-859.57
10/11/18	25,052.83	-545.91	-1405.48
10/12/18	25,339.99	+287.16	-1118.32
10/15/18	25,250.55	-89.44	-1207.76
10/16/18	25,798.42	+547.87	-659.89
10/17/18	25,706.68	-91.74	-751.63
10/18/18	25,379.45	-327.23	-1078.86
10/19/18	25,444.34	+64.89	-1,013.97

At the Close, Friday, October 19, 2018:
Dow Jones Industrial Average: 25,444.34, +64.89 (+0.26%)
NASDAQ: 7,449.03, -36.11 (-0.48%)
S&P 500: 2,767.78, -1.00 (-0.04%)
NYSE Composite: 12,457.27, +11.79 (+0.09%)

For the Week:
Dow: +104.35 (+0.41%)
NASDAQ: -47.87 (-0.64%)
S&P 500: +0.65 (+0.02%)
NYSE Composite: +17.85 (+0.14%)

Stocks Can't Gain Traction; Tech, Industrials Lead Broad Decline

Continuing the stock rout that began in earnest two weeks ago became deeper and more pronounced on Thursday as broad declines sent speculators scurrying for cover.

The Dow Jones Industrial Average recorded its fifth triple-digit loss of the month and its eighth losing session in 14 trading days this month. The index is down nearly 1500 points from the all-time high reached at the close on October 3rd (26.828.39). If this isn't the beginning of a serious correction or bear market, it certainly looks like one.

Only five of the 30 Dow stocks managed gains, led by Verizon (VZ, 54.65, +0.69, +1.28%). Exxon Mobil and Chevron were also among the few winners, despite another day of declines in oil futures, which slumped below $69/barrel for the first time in a month. Mirroring the decline in stocks, WTI crude futures peaked on October 3rd at 76.20, but it's been all downhill since.

Caterpillar (CAT) was the Dow's biggest loser, dragged down nearly four percent on poor results from industry peers. CAT is off nearly 15% since October 3rd.

The other major indices suffered more serious losses, with the NASDAQ leading the way down, losing 157 points, more than a two percent drop. Once again, tech stocks dominated those losing ground, with Netflix, Google, Apple, and Tesla all declining by more than two percent.

There seems to be no escaping the cascade of falling stocks in October, traditionally one of the most volatile months for equities. No sector is particularly a safe haven, though utility stocks have largely been spared, thanks to low alpha and steady dividends.

The Dow needs only to finish Friday with a loss of 39 points or better to avoid a fourth straight weekly decline. A solid close to the week would also allow the S&P and NASDAQ to close out the week with gains, thanks to Tuesday's melt-up advance. However, stocks in Europe are losing ground in early Friday trading.

Dow Jones Industrial Average October Scorecard:

Date	Close	Gain/Loss	Cum. G/L
10/1/18	26,651.21	+192.90	+192.90
10/2/18	26,773.94	+122.73	+315.63
10/3/18	26,828.39	+54.45	+370.08
10/4/18	26,627.48	-200.91	+169.17
10/5/18	26,447.05	-180.43	-11.26
10/8/18	26,486.78	+39.73	+28.47
10/9/18	26,430.57	-56.21	-27.74
10/10/18	25,598.74	-831.83	-859.57
10/11/18	25,052.83	-545.91	-1405.48
10/12/18	25,339.99	+287.16	-1118.32
10/15/18	25,250.55	-89.44	-1207.76
10/16/18	25,798.42	+547.87	-659.89
10/17/18	25,706.68	-91.74	-751.63
10/18/18	25,379.45	-327.23	-1078.86

At the Close, Thursday, October 18, 2018:
Dow Jones Industrial Average: 25,379.45, -327.23 (-1.27%)
NASDAQ: 7,485.14, -157.56 (-2.06%)
S&P 500: 2,768.78, -40.43 (-1.44%)
NYSE Composite: 12,445.48, -167.57 (-1.33%)

Why Stocks Are Unlikely To Go Any Higher

Forget about today's Fed Minutes. Forget about corporate third quarter earnings lowing to markets this week and next, and for the next month.

Forget all the gains made over the past nine years. The market has peaked, and there's good reasons to believe that and data to back it up.

First of all, stocks are wildly overvalued. By many measures, US equities are priced at the highest point they've ever been. Higher than during the dotcom phase, higher than the subprime wildness, stocks today are carrying just plain stupid valuations, like they are darling growth stocks with improving bottom lines. Many are not.

As an example, take Coca-Cola (KO) a standard of the Dow Industrials for many long years. KO is not a growth stock. It's an income stock with a dividend of 1.56, yielding a healthy 3.46% on its share price of around 45. But, here's the kicker. The P/E of Coca-Cola is a whopping 82. That's a number usually reserved for hot tech start-ups, not globally-engaged, long-in-the-tooth mature companies. It's a ridiculous situation because as the price of the stock falls, the dividend yield will rise, making it the attractive investment it is today.

But it's not. If Coke goes from 45 to 35 in a year or two, the dividend yield will be in a higher range. Revenue is falling. Earnings may be stable due to stock buybacks, which is a hidden portfolio killer. Other stocks like Coke exist, like McDonald's, Home Depot, Goldman Sachs, or just about half of the Dow Industrials.

If the simple overvaluation isn't enough to keep people from dumping their money into stocks, then there's the economic data, like unemployment, currently at 3.7%, which is an historic low. Economists generally consider anything below five percent as full employment because there are always a certain number of people changing jobs, retiring, or otherwise out of the employment market.

Inflation is moderate, but interest rates continue to rise, thanks to the Fed. Their rate hikes are putting a much needed brake on what could be a runaway speculative stock market and maybe already is. The Fed isn't going to suddenly stop raising rates, so, as 2018 winds down as a very dull year for stocks, bonds, currencies, and commodities, 2019 is shaping up to be even worse.

IN many ways, President Trump's promise to "Make America Great Again" may already have been kept. America is pretty great already. Anything more would be Nirvana. We've reached a peak. It's time to slow down a little. Recessions are healthy because they clear out excess malinvestment, like Sears, which recently filed for bankruptcy protection. Or Toys 'R Us, which went belly up last year but had been a zombie company for many years prior to its implosion.

There are other issues as well, from political turmoil in Europe, to trade tensions, to the huge credit bubble that's affecting individuals, businesses, and governments. They're all over-leveraged and deeply indebted.

For these reasons, stocks can't really go much higher, if at all. The bull run is coming to an end, but that's not necessarily bad news, it just means that investors will have to be more disciplined if they hope to profit.

Dow Jones Industrial Average October Scorecard:

Date	Close	Gain/Loss	Cum. G/L
10/1/18	26,651.21	+192.90	+192.90
10/2/18	26,773.94	+122.73	+315.63
10/3/18	26,828.39	+54.45	+370.08
10/4/18	26,627.48	-200.91	+169.17
10/5/18	26,447.05	-180.43	-11.26
10/8/18	26,486.78	+39.73	+28.47
10/9/18	26,430.57	-56.21	-27.74
10/10/18	25,598.74	-831.83	-859.57
10/11/18	25,052.83	-545.91	-1405.48
10/12/18	25,339.99	+287.16	-1118.32
10/15/18	25,250.55	-89.44	-1207.76
10/16/18	25,798.42	+547.87	-659.89
10/17/18	25,706.68	-91.74	-751.63

At the Close, Wednesday, October 17, 2018:
Dow Jones Industrial Average: 25,706.68, -91.74 (-0.36%)
NASDAQ: 7,642.70, -2.79 (-0.04%)
S&P 500: 2,809.21, -0.71 (-0.03%)
NYSE Composite: 12,613.05, -32.90 (-0.26%)