Why Does the Dow Go Up When Everything Else Goes Down?

Divergence between the NASDAQ and the Dow Industrials has been a persistent feature over the past year, although recently, the up versus down daily routine has taken on nw dimensions, with the 30 Dow stocks outperforming all other indices routinely.

Tuesday was a case in point as all major indices, including the S&P 500, NASDAQ, Dow Transportation Index, and the Russell 2000 all ended in the red, while the Dow rose majestically to a new all-time closing high. Additionally, almost all foreign markets finished lower on the day.

While there has been no rationale to sufficiently explain the phenomenon, one might easily conclude that the Dow stocks are more stable than the more speculative offerings on other indices, or that Dow stocks, in addition to steady appreciation, offer regular dividends and are generally regarded as the best behemoth companies in the American market.

None of this can fully explain why the Dow gains while other stocks fall, but the pattern has been so obvious and consistent for so long, it merits further investigation.

Conspiracy theorists can claim manipulation in order to keep the unsuspecting masses complacent, as the Dow Jones Industrial Average is the most-widely watched index on the planet. Such an explanation would be difficult, if not impossible, to prove.

Others rightly point out that the Dow is unique in that it is not a weighted average, and gains or losses by the highest-priced offerings can send the index up or down in rather large ways.

In any case, the Dow keeps going up, no matter what other markets or indices are doing.

Dow Jones Industrial Average October Scorecard:

Date	Close	Gain/Loss	Cum. G/L
10/1/18	26,651.21	+192.90	+192.90
10/2/18	26,773.94	+122.73	+315.63

At the Close, Tuesday, October 2, 2018:
Dow Jones Industrial Average: 26,773.94, +122.73 (+0.46%)
NASDAQ: 7,999.55, -37.76 (-0.47%)
S&P 500: 2,923.43, -1.16 (-0.04%)
NYSE Composite: 13,106.01, -19.34 (-0.15%)